COM208U - Native Americans and the Media

Professor: Dr. Scott Sochay Dept. of Communication Studies
Office: HC327F Fall 2024
Office Hours: M, W, F 9 - 10 am, H noon - 2 pm and by appt. Time: Section 1: M, W, F 11:10 - 12:20
Office Phone: (651) 638-6199 Location: RC228
Home Phone: (517) 648-7759 (before 8:30 pm) PO Box 51
email: socsco@bethel.edu Back to Sochay home page

Required Text:

LaDuke, Winona (1997). Last Standing Woman, Stillwater, MN: Voyageur Press or Dimaline, Cherie (2017). Marrow Thieves. Toronto, ONT: DCB Books.

Sochay, Scott (2007). Native Americans and the Media reading packet.

World Cultures (U-tag) courses at Bethel give students the opportunity to think critically about the traditions, frameworks, and structures of cultures that are different from their own. As a result of taking this course, students should be able to recognize the diverse perspectives and lived experiences of neighbors and colleagues and demonstrate flexibility by adapting to diverse environments.

Course Objectives:

Students will:

  1. understand that there is no one Native American culture and learn to identify stereotypes;
  2. investigate and become class expert on one major Indian tribe;
  3. be exposed to Native American voices and learn how to access Native American voices - both historic and contemporary;
  4. develop critical skills to analyze Native American media portrayals and; 
  5. be able to compare and contrast social and media criticisms of Native American portrayals.

As a U-tag, this course has related gen ed outcomes:

Knowledge
1. Identify the interconnectedness of the culture being studied with other world cultures.
2. Understand worldviews and ways of life from a variety of perspectives, including Christian perspectives.
3. Analyze how culture has been transmitted and changed due to the influence of time, environment, and other cultures.
Skills
1. Develop a vocabulary that allows discourse between the culture being studied and one's own.
2. Show empathy to and engagement with the ideas, points of view, and feelings of others when these differ from one's own.
 

 

 

Grading and Expectations:

Participation is important and is part of your grade. Students are expected to have read the required chapters for each class session and be prepared to discuss its contents. A lack of preparation not only hurts your grade it also takes away from the quality of the in-class discussion and makes the learning experience less enjoyable for your classmates. Attendance is also a part of your participation grade. Excessive absences and/or tardiness will be reflected in that generally, three or more unexcused absences will result in a minimum one grade lower participation grade. The University policy on attendance can be found in the Bethel catalog.

Projects are due at the beginning of the class period noted in the course outline. Late projects or missed exams will not be accepted without a legitimate excuse such as medical illness or emergency. If you have a situation that may present difficulties in turning a project in on time or making an exam date the proper procedure is to discuss this with me before the due date. I'm flexible and understanding when students talk with me before an assignment or exam is due. I'm much less flexible if a student tries to explain their situation after the due date has passed. In short, if you think you're going to have a problem turning in an assignment on time, talk with me before the due date. The same also applies to attendance. Excused absences are at my discretion. I am far more likely to grant them when students let me know ahead of time (when possible) or contact me as soon as possible after the missed class.

Any/all assignments should be submitted in hard copy form. Any exceptions to this will be announced in class.

Student work will be evaluated according to the guidelines laid out in the Bethel University catalog. To receive an "A," work should be "exceptional". "B" work is considered "good," and "C" "work "satisfactory" and so on. If you have any questions about assignments, ask! If there are concerns about grading, the Complaint and Appeals Procedure can be found at: http://cas.bethel.edu/academics/catalog/.

Violation of honesty standards can result in denial or credit (U or F) in a course, as well as dismissal from the university. Penalties are given at the discretion of the faculty member, and offenders may be referred to the vice president and dean. (See Bethel University’s full policy on Academic Honesty in the catalog: (http://catalog.bethel.edu/arts-sciences/general-information/academic-honesty/).

The student will seek to resolve the matter first with the instructor or with the party directly responsible for the decision, and then with the department chair. (If the instructor is the department chair, the student should contact the Dean of Academic Programs.) If after talking with the instructor and the department chair the matter is not resolved, the student may appeal in writing to the Dean of Academic Programs. This written appeal must be received within three weeks of the decision. (See Bethel University’s full policy on Academic Appeals in the catalog: http://catalog.bethel.edu/arts-sciences/general-information/academic-appeals/).

Accessibility Statement:

Bethel University is committed to accessibility for students with disabilities and the Office of Accessibility Resources & Services (OARS) is a resource to ensure students experience access. Reasonable accommodations are approved after an interactive process with the student and OARS. The instructor will provide accommodations, but the student is required to initiate the process.

Support for Multilingual Learners Statement:

 

Points will be awarded for the course as follows:

Tribal presentation 50 points
Star Trek 25 points
LSW/Marrow Thieves paper 50 points
History Presentation 25 points
Film Analysis paper 50 points
Attendance/Participation 25 points
Total 225 points

 

Final grades will be based on the cumulative number of points earned on the assignments noted above. Accumulated points will be divided by the total points available (250) to arrive at a percentage for the course. Grades will be assigned based on the following scale:

A

= 93-100%

C+

= 77-79

A-

= 90-92

C

= 73-76

B+

= 87-89

C-

= 70-72

B

= 83-86

D+

= 67-69

B-

= 80-82

D

= 60-66

   

F

= below 60

       

 

LSW/Marrow Thieves paper:

After reading LSW or Marrow Thieves (and the pdf on Native American literature) write a 3-5 page paper exploring the following:

What is your response to the novel - what did you like/not like? What did you think of plot, character development, story line etc?

Explore the question of Native American literature - Did LSW/Marrow Thieves follow the conventions of Native American literature (as we looked at in the Literature lecture, Thamarana's article, and also including the Guidelines and any course material you've learned so far)? THIS IS THE KEY SECTION OF THE PAPER.

How does LSW/Marrow Thieves differ from other novels you have read - is there a cultural distinctive to the book?

The LSW/Marrow Thieves paper assesses U-tag objectives S1 and S2.

Film Analysis paper:

Write a 5-7 page paper that critiques a major Hollywood film in terms of its portrayal of Native Americans. You are required to find at least 3 outside sources to bolster your critique. Analyze the film in terms of criteria given in class when we looked at movies and any criteria/commentary from your outside sources that sheds light on how the film relates to the portrayal of Native Americans. You may also use the Guidelines and any course material you've learned. Your movie must be approved. Movies must be American films made by a major Hollywood studio within the last 50 years. You may not choose Peter Pan or Dances With Wolves. In addition, you may not choose independent films such as Smoke Signals or Skins. Examples of movies that have been used in the past: Pocahontas, Windtalkers, Hostiles, Wind River, Brother Bear, Last of the Mohicans, The Lone Ranger. You are not limited to these examples!

The film analysis paper assesses U-tag objectives S1 and S2.

Tribal presentation:

Students will give a 10-12 minute presentation on a selected tribe. More info will be given in class. The professor will demonstrate possible content to cover. Students will be expected to cover their tribe's history, culture, and contemporary life, as well as making Biblical connections.

The tribes - Cherokee, Navajo, Choctaw, Sioux, Apache, Blackfeet, Iroquois, Pueblo, Creek/Seminole, Hopi, Salish, Comanche

The tribal presentation assesses U-tag objectives K2 and K3.

History Presentation:

Groups will be assigned a portion of the history section of the class. Each group will put together a presentation that addresses the historical situation from Native and non-Native perspectives. Presentations should be in the 10 minute range.

The history presentation assesses U-tag objectives K1 and K2.

Star Trek response paper:

Write a 2-3 page paper on the three Star Trek episodes. How did you see Native Americans portrayed? How did that portrayal change over time? How do the portrayals fit/not fit with the stereotypes we've gone over in class? Use the Guidelines questions, the TV and film themes, and any course material you've learned so far to do the analysis.

The Star Trek paper assesses U-tag objectives S1 and S2.

ALL THREE PAPERS SHOULD BE SUBMITTED IN HARD COPY FORM

 

 

Tentative Course Outline and Assignments:

9/4 Introduction  
9/6 What does it mean to be Indian?/My Journey What does it mean to be Indian?
9/9 What does it mean to be Indian/History Native History
9/11 We Shall Remain
9/13 We Shall Remain/History Presentations work time  
9/16 History (with presentations)
9/18 History (wth presentations)  
9/20 History Native Religion and Christianity
9/23 Native Religions and Christianity/Ojibwe Ojibwa/Odawa
9/25 Tribal presentations workday  
9/27 Tribal presentations workday  
9/30 Tribal presentations Film Approval
10/2 Tribal presentations  
10/4 FALL BREAK  
10/7 No Class
10/9 Film lecture Film
10/11 Broken Arrow  
10/14 Broken Arrow discussion  
10/16 Reel Injun  
10/18 Reel Injun/ News lecture Newspapers
10/21 Literature lecture Literature
10/23 Newspapers (online)  
10/25 Newspapers (online)  
10/28 Newspapers (online) Film analysis due
10/30 ADVISING DAY  
11/1 TV lecture Television
11/4 TV workday  
11/6 TV Presentations
11/8 TV Presentations  
11/11 How Natives present themselves through TV  
11/13 Star Trek  
11/15 Star Trek  
11/18 Star Trek  
11/20 Literature paper workday  
11/22 Literature discussion (LSW/Marrow Thieves) LSW/Marrow Thieves paper due
11/25 Catch up day  
11/27 - 29 INDIGENOUS PEOPLES DAY  
12/2 Native Americans and Music  
12/4 Native Americans and Music/ Superheroes  
12/6 Superheroes/Mascots Star Trek paper due
12/9 How Natives present themselves through film  
12/11 How Natives present themselves through film  
12/13 How Natives present themselves through film  
     
12/19 Final 11:30 - 1:30

 

 

The 5 Stages

1. Learn the Native culture/s

2. Look at media portrayals of Native cultures

3. What do scholars say about those portrayals?

4. What do Natives say about those portrayals?

5. How do Natives choose to portray themselves through media?

 

 

 

 

Comics